| Year |
Final Score |
Winning Coach |
Location |
| 1973 |
South Bend Washington 19, Indianapolis Cathedral 13 |
Bob Van Camp |
South Bend Washington |
| 1974 |
Indianapolis Washington 19, Mishawaka 12 |
Bob Springer |
Indianapolis Washington |
| 1975 |
Valparaiso 14, Carmel 13 |
Tom Stokes |
Valparaiso |
| 1976 |
Merrillville 28, Indianapolis Cathedral 24 |
Ken Haupt |
Indianapolis Cathedral |
| 1977 |
Portage 33, Evansville Reitz 14 |
Les Klein |
North Central (Indianapolis) |
| 1978 |
Carmel 35, Fort Wayne Dwenger 18 |
Dick Dullaghan |
North Central (Indianapolis) |
| 1979 |
Columbus East 21, Hobart 14 |
John Stafford |
North Central (Indianapolis) |
| 1980 |
Carmel 13, Hobart 7 |
Jim Belden |
North Central (Indianapolis) |
| 1981 |
Carmel 27, Fort Wayne Snider 0 |
Jim Belden |
North Central (Indianapolis) |
| 1982 |
Castle 26, Hobart 23 |
John Lidy |
North Central (Indianapolis) |
| 1983 |
Fort Wayne Dwenger 22, Roncalli 21 |
Andy Johns |
Warren Central |
| 1984 |
Brownsburg 17, Concord 12 |
Mike Godan |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1985 |
Roncalli 37, Wawasee 3 |
Bill Kuntz |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1986 |
Indianapolis Cathedral 12, NorthWood 0 |
Mike McGinley |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1987 |
Zionsville 23, Elwood 7 |
Rick Wimmer |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1988 |
Roncalli 14, Tipton 13 |
Bill Sylvester |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1989 |
Hammond Noll 20, Roncalli 14 |
Jerry Vlasic |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1990 |
Fort Wayne Dwenger 56, New Palestine 14 |
Andy Johns |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1991 |
Fort Wayne Dwenger 34, Indianapolis Cathedral 27 |
Andy Johns |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1992 |
Indianapolis Cathedral 33, Northwestern 14 |
Rick Streiff |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1993 |
Roncalli 14, NorthWood 12 |
Bruce Scifres |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1994 |
Roncalli 35, Tipton 14 |
Bruce Scifres |
RCA Dome |
| 1995 |
South Bend St. Joseph’s 28, Jasper 0 |
Frank Amato |
RCA Dome |
| 1996 |
Zionsville 14, Fort Wayne Dwenger 7 |
Larry McWhorter |
RCA Dome |
| 1997 |
Indianapolis Chatard 27, Andrean 24 |
Craig Barr |
RCA Dome |
| 1998 |
Indianapolis Chatard 23, NorthWood 6 |
Craig Barr |
RCA Dome |
| 1999 |
Roncalli 24, Norwell 14 |
Bruce Scifres |
RCA Dome |
| 2000 |
Heritage Hills 27, Zionsville 24, OT |
Bob Clayton |
RCA Dome |
| 2001 |
Indianapolis Chatard 3, Andrean 0 |
Tom Dilley |
RCA Dome |
| 2002 |
Indianapolis Chatard 31, Andrean 12 |
Tom Dilley |
RCA Dome |
| 2003 |
Indianapolis Chatard 39, NorthWood 0 |
Vince Lorenzano |
RCA Dome |
| 2004 |
Andrean 21, Heritage Hills 14 |
Brett St. Germain |
RCA Dome |
| 2005 |
NorthWood 7, Indianapolis Chatard 0 |
Rich Dodson |
RCA Dome |
| 2006 |
Indianapolis Chatard 7, Norwell 0 |
Vince Lorenzano |
RCA Dome |
| 2007 |
Indianapolis Chatard 31, South Bend St. Joseph's |
Vince Lorenzano |
RCA Dome |
| 2008 |
Bellmont 28, Evansville Memorial 14 |
Toney Bergman |
Lucas Oil Stadium |
| 2009 |
West Lafayette 24, Evansville Memorial 10 |
Marshall Overley |
Lucas Oil Stadium |
| 2010 |
Indianapolis Chatard 28, South Bend St. Joseph’s 14 |
Vince Lorenzano |
Lucas Oil Stadium |
